Oscar Wilde's best-known foray into the novel has been filmed umpteen times, its central theme of the corrupting influence of hedonism on the soul continuing to exert a powerful pull which transcends the original setting of genteel Victorian high society. But it's important to understand that it's the necessarily unspoken subtext - The Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name - that gives the story its dramatic rationale. A literal reading will fall flat, and more so with each passing generation, for whom a life of irresponsible sex and opium use will not readily equate to an irredeemable tainting of the spirit, and unfortunately this is the trap that Parker's film falls unwittingly into.
The teen-friendly casting of The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian's admirably cheek-boned but tonally rangeless Ben Barnes in the lead role does not help matters, but neither does Colin Firth's decision to swallow even more of his lips and vowels as Gray's vicarious mentor-in-cynicism and aphorisms, Wilde's alter ego Henry Wotton, or the superfluous addition to the story of Wotton's daughter as a potential beacon of hope. Also, the normally reliable Roger Pratt's cinematography lurches from high art to TV soap, though the jarring insertion of unnecessary flashbacks hardly aids him in establishing a stylistic continuity.
So, it ends up suffering in comparison not only with another recent adaptation of a great novel about a period sociopath, to wit Tom Tykwer's Perfume: The Story of a Murderer, but also with Albert Lewin's 1945 rendering, which may seem stiflingly mannered now but did have the virtue of letting our imagination do the work instead of the stock footage decadence on show here.
5/10
Monday, 15 February 2010
Friday, 12 February 2010
¿Qué he hecho yo para merecer esto!! (Pedro Almodóvar, 1984)
What Have I Done to Deserve This? may be early enough in Almodóvar's portfolio that the unique formula is as yet unrefined, but all the ingredients are in place: a medicated housewife harried to hysteria (Carmen Maura, in the first of many Almodóvar lead roles), hypocritical artists, sexually precocious kids, a whore with a heart of gold and a folkwise long-suffering grandma. All of the above yammer incessantly at each other, and the parrot house effect is accentuated by there seeming to be no one in Madrid besides the dozen characters, whose paths keep on crossing in unlikely ways. So it's hardly surprising when Maura's character, less stress-proofed than in her later roles, does eventually flip, and this just irons out a kink in the fabric of the story.
The dialogue and set-ups are also good for intermittent nervous laughter, and if in the end Almodóvar clearly hasn't decided whether he was making a black comedy or a serious drama, it's no great dereliction of directorial duty as we're nevertheless guided quite logically to a close securely in the realm of urban parable.
6/10
The dialogue and set-ups are also good for intermittent nervous laughter, and if in the end Almodóvar clearly hasn't decided whether he was making a black comedy or a serious drama, it's no great dereliction of directorial duty as we're nevertheless guided quite logically to a close securely in the realm of urban parable.
6/10
Tuesday, 9 February 2010
Changeling (Clint Eastwood, 2008)
In one sense, Dirty Harry comes full circle like a snake biting its tail, with a piece which in no uncertain terms presents the LAPD of the ‘20s as a bastion of corruption and intimidation. Meanwhile, in a wider thematic context, we’re still with Eastwood’s perennial loner struggling against the injustice of a prejudiced system. In this case, it’s Angelina Jolie, a single mother whose child vanishes. The police and state apparatus, amidst much self-congratulatory fanfare, duly present her with another child and pressure her into accepting the stranger as her own. When she repeatedly denies parenthood of the boy, the irritation of the police turns to ire and then results in her committal to a mental institution.
The sheer insanity of a set-up in which the authorities, being experts, assert their identification of the child over the febrile female capacity of the actual mother, would be cartoonishly unfeasible without the certitude that we’re dealing with real-life events here. Accepting their factuality gives Eastwood a strong hand indeed with which to make a double assault on both self-serving bureaucracy and the disenfranchisement of women.
But adherence to the facts of the case also pushes the film structurally badly off course: everything is effectively resolved with an hour still to go, and then we’ve just got a succession of stolid epilogues to wade through. And, as for Jolie, irrespective of her public image as a serial maternalist, and Oscar-nominated though she was – presumably for the feat of working outside gunplay or vamping – she’s an ill fit for the role of a vulnerable everywoman, too glam and too steely: it’s all too easy to envisage her pushed over the edge and beating the crap out of her institutional oppressors.
But adherence to the facts of the case also pushes the film structurally badly off course: everything is effectively resolved with an hour still to go, and then we’ve just got a succession of stolid epilogues to wade through. And, as for Jolie, irrespective of her public image as a serial maternalist, and Oscar-nominated though she was – presumably for the feat of working outside gunplay or vamping – she’s an ill fit for the role of a vulnerable everywoman, too glam and too steely: it’s all too easy to envisage her pushed over the edge and beating the crap out of her institutional oppressors.
5/10
Thursday, 4 February 2010
Largo Winch (Jérôme Salle, 2008)
It's a risky venture for an action film to aim for emotional resonance, and the Daniel Craig Bond reboot franchise seems to have given up on the attempt just two films in, settling for duelling with the Michael Bay juggernaut in the skid-bang-wallop stakes instead, falling between two stools and thoroughly mangling its assets in the process. But the first Bourne film managed it, so the golden formula must exist...
The ludicrously-monikered Largo Winch is the hero of a long-running series of bande dessinée, a medium which has bafflingly broad popularity across the adult Francophone world, unmatched anywhere else, barring Japan, regardless of any 'graphic novel'-rebranding attempts. This tells you what to expect: glossy violence, with affectations towards back stories and concerns with character psyches. This is, of course, pretty much what Bond adds up to, and large parts of the film are a smudged carbon copy of a Bond, right down to the soundtrack, with vulpinely smirking male model with sticky-up rebel hair Tomer Sisley scampering his way to gaining control of the multi-national bequeathed to him by his late adoptive father whilst Kristin Scott-Thomas and assorted mafia machinate away against his rise.
You might see the fairly sparing use of action, as far the genre goes, as a sign of a mature hand at the helm, but bear in mind that for the target audience this is the 'origin' part, getting the necessary evil of exposition out of the way to let the inevitable sequels run amok. As it is, the action actually provides some relief from the hackneyed back story, if only by virtue of at least being efficiently handled.
4/10
The ludicrously-monikered Largo Winch is the hero of a long-running series of bande dessinée, a medium which has bafflingly broad popularity across the adult Francophone world, unmatched anywhere else, barring Japan, regardless of any 'graphic novel'-rebranding attempts. This tells you what to expect: glossy violence, with affectations towards back stories and concerns with character psyches. This is, of course, pretty much what Bond adds up to, and large parts of the film are a smudged carbon copy of a Bond, right down to the soundtrack, with vulpinely smirking male model with sticky-up rebel hair Tomer Sisley scampering his way to gaining control of the multi-national bequeathed to him by his late adoptive father whilst Kristin Scott-Thomas and assorted mafia machinate away against his rise.
You might see the fairly sparing use of action, as far the genre goes, as a sign of a mature hand at the helm, but bear in mind that for the target audience this is the 'origin' part, getting the necessary evil of exposition out of the way to let the inevitable sequels run amok. As it is, the action actually provides some relief from the hackneyed back story, if only by virtue of at least being efficiently handled.
4/10
Friday, 22 January 2010
The Visitor (Thomas McCarthy, 2007)
Journeyman actor McCarthy has only delved into feature directing once before, with 2003's quietly affecting The Station Agent, and delivers something of a similar emotional tone here with a tale of a shy widowed college professor who is drawn out of his shell when he finds an illegal immigrant couple occupying his New York flat, and invites them to stay on. In the traditions of the internationalist scenario where cultures meet and enrich the lives of all concerned, he finds a sense of purpose and attachment along the way. It would be easy to trip into cheesiness with this set-up, but a combination of Richard Jenkins's sensitive (and Oscar-nominated) reading of the professor warily opening up and McCarthy's lightness of touch with essentially staple material makes for a satisfyingly true-to-life whole, and also an undidactic one, despite its obvious indignation at the status quo. Neither the protagonist nor the illegal immigrants are idealised portraits of nobility or suffering, but believably rounded, vulnerable beings under the impersonally oppressive yoke of US post-9/11 bureaucracy.
7/10
Monday, 18 January 2010
The Road (John Hillcoat, 2009)
Even in the present cinematic climate of apocalypticism, engendered largely by the America vs Islam stand-off and the preponderance of environmental disaster/2012 scenarios, it's surprising to find Oscar consideration touching on a film as utterly devoid of hope as The Road. Viggo Mortensen and Kodi Smit-McPhee, as The Man and The Boy, wander through a cursed land, littered with the broken and the dying, and the strength of their relationship forms the only impetus for them to continue on a futile quest for sanctuary. Like Cormac McCarthy's feted source work, this isn't interested in scientific explanations for the end of the world. This frees the barren land to act as a symbol of impending doom; the death that will eventually separate all sons from their fathers, and the characters remaining unnamed hammers home the symbolism.
Hillcoat's last feature, the gritty Outback Western The Proposition, was already saturated in earth hues, dust and grim senses of purpose. Here, all are taken a step beyond as the remaining colour is drained out, rust and rot coat everything and all motivations become last crutches. The starkly visualised devastation of the landscape is reflected in the ravagement of the characters' faces and souls, bar the untouched Boy, lingering icon of life. Mortensen's performance is agonisingly tender and helps, alongside the plot's avoidance of survival horror cliches in the midst of cannibals, to keep us linked into the universal human theme beneath the potentially overpowering metaphor. Indeed, if there is a criticism, it's that the symbolism is too heavy-handed, the characters just cyphers. But it will get under your skin regardless.
8/10
Sunday, 17 January 2010
Johnny Mad Dog (Jean-Stéphane Sauvaire, 2008)
Set in Liberia, but in effect in a generic war-torn African country, Sauvaire's harrowing account of a marauding band of boy soldiers bears some echoes of City of God in its depiction of feral anarchy. As in Meirelles's searing masterpiece, the sense of horror arises from manifold sources: the perverse blend of the childlike - one boy sports a pair of angel wings - with the grimly systematic adult military organisation of their assaults, the matter-of-fact way characters intermittently keel over and die, dispatched by unseen enemies, and the utter lack of humanity remaining within the boys, who cannot remember their families and therefore are unable to empathise with the civilians they prey on. It's a hopeless scenario, which leaves even the innocent either dead or emotionally brutalised, but the nihilism is essential to a just portrayal of what news reportage may routinely have to gloss over.7/10
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



