By all rights, this should have been a catastrophe on the scale of Ballistic: Ecks vs. Sever. Not only shackled by having to stretch out a back story that has already been adequately explained, but stuck with the necessity to bridge a continuity gap to an increasingly wobbly moneyspinner on the strength of Hugh Jackman's admittedly impressive pecs and glower alone. So it comes as quite a revelation that a decent director actually took this on. If you haven't seen Hood's township crime drama Tsotsi, do. He's managed to invest a bogstandard torrent of superhero hack-and-slash script with enough wit that it's not only not painful, but probably because of lowered expectations, quite entertaining. Plus Liev Schreiber is maybe one of the most charismatic heroes or villains that Hollywood has to give us, now that the likes of Jack Palance are gone.
5/10
Saturday, 27 March 2010
Terminator Salvation (McG, 2009)
...in which the remaining life gets squeezed out of a franchise which already seemed to be DOA, by a director whose name you'd be forgiven for doing a double-take on. Surely it can only be an Alan Smithee-type pseudonym? No, this one really exists and it's no surprise that pop videos are pretty much the extent of his oeuvre. This turns out as a lot of directionless sound and fury, which manages to divert just by virtue of its relentless pace, but will infuriate anyone wishing for plot continuity or any other purpose as to why it was made. Granite-jawed Ben Affleck-a-like Sam Worthington wakes up in the nightmare future and is rather upset to find out he's not wholly human any more. Christian Bale scowls a lot. The past gets rewritten once again. And that's about all.
4/10
4/10
Friday, 12 March 2010
Mon Meilleur Ami (Patrice Leconte, 2006)
My Best Friend lets permafixture of French cinema of the last twenty years, Daniel Auteuil, exercise his harassed hangdog character to the full as antisocial Paris antique dealer Francois Coste, who's challenged by his business partner to come up with proof of having at least one friend. His path eventually crosses that of a quizshow-obsessive taxi driver (Dany Boon) who agrees to take him under his wing to give him pointers on how to avoid scaring people off.
All the ingredients for a light comedy, then, in the mould of Le Dîner de Cons, but this is Patrice Leconte and the closest he ever gets to comedy is something like the combat of acid wit of 1996's Ridicule. The intent here is clearly social comment on loneliness, but the point gets lost amidst Coste's circle of accusers all coming across as lacking human warmth far more than the accused, whereas he should have started out truly unlikeable to pack some emotional welly into his inevitable Damascene conversion. Still, a dependably Auteuilistic turn and an endearing one from Boon pull us through the briars.
6/10
All the ingredients for a light comedy, then, in the mould of Le Dîner de Cons, but this is Patrice Leconte and the closest he ever gets to comedy is something like the combat of acid wit of 1996's Ridicule. The intent here is clearly social comment on loneliness, but the point gets lost amidst Coste's circle of accusers all coming across as lacking human warmth far more than the accused, whereas he should have started out truly unlikeable to pack some emotional welly into his inevitable Damascene conversion. Still, a dependably Auteuilistic turn and an endearing one from Boon pull us through the briars.
6/10
Saturday, 20 February 2010
District 9 (Neill Blomkamp, 2009)
Aliens have come to Earth, and for once it's not New York or L.A. they've ended up over, but Johannesburg. This is just the first of refreshing twists to the usual first contact scenario. More follow: they turn out to be neither unstoppable invaders nor more spiritually evolved, but disempowered dregs of their society, uncultured and ill-tempered, with a cat-food fixation to boot. And humanity's best response to the unwanted new burden is to seek to lose them in the labyrinths of the social security system, an underclass to be bamboozled with legalese and shunted from shantytown to shantytown. The allegory with the apartheid situation of the past is so central that its lack of subtlety is even an asset, enforced by the blackly satirical documentary style.
Then, as a government official assigned the task of relocating the undesirables to an internment camp is exposed to chemicals which cause him to begin transmuting into one of the loathsome 'prawns', the film begins to veer off course. His change is a disintegration straight out of Cronenberg's The Fly, the authorities turn on him as a potential bioweapon to be exploited à la Robocop, and by the end we're in an unending township gun battle which is uncertainly pitched between African militia warfare and Transformers, with a murderous Nigerian gang after all providing the barbaric black villains we thought might have been avoided. It's a pity because the initial premise suggested much more. Marks for novel details, then, but not the final outcome in an uneven ride.
6/10
Then, as a government official assigned the task of relocating the undesirables to an internment camp is exposed to chemicals which cause him to begin transmuting into one of the loathsome 'prawns', the film begins to veer off course. His change is a disintegration straight out of Cronenberg's The Fly, the authorities turn on him as a potential bioweapon to be exploited à la Robocop, and by the end we're in an unending township gun battle which is uncertainly pitched between African militia warfare and Transformers, with a murderous Nigerian gang after all providing the barbaric black villains we thought might have been avoided. It's a pity because the initial premise suggested much more. Marks for novel details, then, but not the final outcome in an uneven ride.
6/10
Yella (Christian Petzold, 2007)
A young woman with a possessive husband in an eastern German backwater wants out, but he won't allow it. This culminates in him unilaterally deciding on their suicide. Yella, however, gets away and finds a new life in Hanover with a private equity company, where her new boss takes a shine to her, as much as for her calculating ruthlessness in their shared predatory moves on ailing companies as for her other attributes. But it becomes evident that her attempt to distance herself from the past has failed...
Petzold's film teems under a thin skin with the supernatural, and there is an effective understated eeriness to the overall tone. But the central characters remain too glacially inexpressive and unsympathetic to ever really engage interest. Also, it's far too easy to deduce early on which Hollywood chiller the plot is clearly drawn from, and it doesn't add anything to the original despite the attempts to create a new focus with the corporate nastiness.
5/10
Petzold's film teems under a thin skin with the supernatural, and there is an effective understated eeriness to the overall tone. But the central characters remain too glacially inexpressive and unsympathetic to ever really engage interest. Also, it's far too easy to deduce early on which Hollywood chiller the plot is clearly drawn from, and it doesn't add anything to the original despite the attempts to create a new focus with the corporate nastiness.
5/10
Friday, 19 February 2010
Star Trek (J.J. Abrams, 2009)
A key question with reboots of megabuck franchises is always whether taking the easy option of capitalising on goodwill and familiarity with a set of characters and precepts is outweighed by what's been added. Certainly, the example set by Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins holds up as a model for what a bold enough director can accomplish, revitalising a character who'd become mired in pointless tongue-in-cheekery in previous outings. As for the last Star Trek films, a series of recycled TV episode themes with some extra CGI frills pointed to a niggling and inevitable demise.
So, how does Star Trek stack up? Trekkies will probably leave apoplectic and gratiated in equal measure: Abrams has cheerfully plundered anything that took his fancy from the whole existing canon, jumped up the octane level and given half the cast a brief to summon up their best impersonations of the original '60s characterisations, Karl Urban's Bones McCoy the most shameless of the lot. This all works to good effect: the frenetic japery throughout is a welcome switch from the stolid po-facedness of the last Treks. Abrams also sidesteps the pitfall of inconsistency with the established canon quite neatly by recourse to that most traditional Trek MacGuffin, the alternate timeline, and works in additional insurance by having Leonard Nimoy, as the Spock from the future, hand over his blessing to his younger self and the reboot itself.
It's easy to forget amidst such a cornucopia of thrills that a plot might be required too: what substitutes for one is a stock Trek set-up of the growling baddie from the future with a justifiable grievance who wants to destroy Earth. And Abrams also makes a misjudgement common to first-time sci-fi directors, namely that the far-fetched setting does not excuse dramatic implausibility. But the sheer verve on display just about carries the day.
6/10
So, how does Star Trek stack up? Trekkies will probably leave apoplectic and gratiated in equal measure: Abrams has cheerfully plundered anything that took his fancy from the whole existing canon, jumped up the octane level and given half the cast a brief to summon up their best impersonations of the original '60s characterisations, Karl Urban's Bones McCoy the most shameless of the lot. This all works to good effect: the frenetic japery throughout is a welcome switch from the stolid po-facedness of the last Treks. Abrams also sidesteps the pitfall of inconsistency with the established canon quite neatly by recourse to that most traditional Trek MacGuffin, the alternate timeline, and works in additional insurance by having Leonard Nimoy, as the Spock from the future, hand over his blessing to his younger self and the reboot itself.
It's easy to forget amidst such a cornucopia of thrills that a plot might be required too: what substitutes for one is a stock Trek set-up of the growling baddie from the future with a justifiable grievance who wants to destroy Earth. And Abrams also makes a misjudgement common to first-time sci-fi directors, namely that the far-fetched setting does not excuse dramatic implausibility. But the sheer verve on display just about carries the day.
6/10
Monday, 15 February 2010
Volver (Pedro Almodóvar, 2006)
The title Volver, translating as 'coming back', can be neatly read as both the return from the dead of Carmen Maura's mother character in this film, and also Almodóvar's own revisiting of the milieu of What Have I Done to Deserve This?, 20 years earlier, which also starred Maura. There's plenty more overt linkage between the two: both centre around a ballsy but highly-strung mother striving to hold her family together; the setting of a nondescript working-class Madrid suburb is much the same, as is the overall tone which treads a fine line between the kitchen-sink dramatic, fantastical and blackly comic...and the abusive father of the family is killed unintentionally in a domestic row.
What makes Volver superior to its predecessor, however, is Almodóvar's evident mastery of his box of tricks: the signature touches are all still there, including his continuing interest in female solidarity, but less garishly or haphazardly displayed, and the transitions from titters to pathos glide rather than jerk. It's also a revelation to finally see Penélope Cruz command the centre stage with such magnetism: upholstered on Almodóvar's instructions to evoke Anna Magnani or Sophia Loren in similarly strong earth-mother roles, she exudes determination, vanity and sensuality in equal measure.
7/10
What makes Volver superior to its predecessor, however, is Almodóvar's evident mastery of his box of tricks: the signature touches are all still there, including his continuing interest in female solidarity, but less garishly or haphazardly displayed, and the transitions from titters to pathos glide rather than jerk. It's also a revelation to finally see Penélope Cruz command the centre stage with such magnetism: upholstered on Almodóvar's instructions to evoke Anna Magnani or Sophia Loren in similarly strong earth-mother roles, she exudes determination, vanity and sensuality in equal measure.
7/10
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






