Sunday, 11 October 2009

La habitación de Fermat (Luis Piedrahita & Rodrigo Sopeña, 2007)

Fermat's Room taps into the popular perception of the obsessive mathematical genius (see A Beautiful Mind), driven into a mania by the hidden truth behind the numbers and liable to form deadly rivalries with their counterparts in the quest for perfection. Much like another group whose work the layperson doesn't really understand, then, i.e. composers.
Four minds are invited by a man hiding behind the pseudonym of Fermat to a deserted farmhouse with the challenge of solving the greatest of conundrums. This promises a great deal, as they find themselves locked in a room with the power to kill them unless they continue cracking a succession of timed riddles.
Except that the link to the actual Fermat is utterly spurious: the makers cop out swiftly at this point in the script and instead present a series of brainteasers familiar from puzzlebooks with no particular relevance to mathematics. Having flaunted the prospect of an intellectual work-out, and then at least the visceral kick of an entrapment horror piece like Cube, they deliver neither.

5/10

Tuesday, 6 October 2009

Låt den rätte komma in (Tomas Alfredson, 2008)

Let the Right One in comes in the midst of a deluge of re-imaginings on vampirism, given fresh blood as a genre by the teen emo culture, that anaemic take on '80s goth. This is unfortunate, as it's best viewed as a growing-up drama instead, which is only added a chill and frisson by the horror theme.
And it's a superior example of either genre, the sense of confusion and otherness of the alienated pubescent bolstered by the haunted outsider status of the nightstalker. The idiosyncratic two young leads do much to contribute to its power, and the glacial setting of an anonymous mid-winter early-'80s Swedish suburb, beautifully framed and lit, make for a whole that far transcends what may seem to be stock ingredients. There hasn't been a vampire film this good in terms of rising above the genre cliches since Bigelow's Near Dark, and beyond that it holds its own against acclaimed coming-of-age pieces such as Stand by Me or The 400 Blows.

8/10

Tôkyô monogatari (Yasujiro Ozu, 1953)

Age withers as well as ripens. Tokyo Story, almost always as the sole Japanese representative, save for the occasional Kurosawa, crops up on Western critics' lists of the best films ever made. Do not let this prejudice you.
It's just a simple, well-crafted tale of an elderly couple making their final rounds around their children's preoccupied lives. They're met with irritable tolerance by all but for their widowed daughter-in-law, and their stoic acceptance of how things are when the progeny view their progenitors as just a burden must have struck a deep and shocking chord in a Japan just on the mend from the ravages of the war. That it manages to speak to audiences worldwide is very much down to the beautifully understated performances of the elderly duo, and, above all a prevailing sense that we're dealing with a universal emotional truth.

7/10

Thursday, 17 September 2009

Happy-Go-Lucky (Mike Leigh, 2008)

Mike Leigh's films have always gone for a naturalistic feel, where commonplace people with drab lives undergo small dramas and discover little diamonds of positivity in the muck. Happy-Go-Lucky may be a step further towards a feelgood experience than most of his previous output, but is still in the same vein and could not feasibly be attributed to any other filmmaker in its formula of banality unmasking fundamental truths.
It revolves around a few weeks in the life of 30-year-old schoolteacher Poppy, a nuclear-poweredly irrepressible chirp machine who embodies the film's title. What little plot there is hangs on her driving lessons with a bag of pent-up Little Englander indignation, played finely between comedy and pathetic pathos by Eddie Marsan, and the scenes between them are by far the most substantial parts of the film. As for the rest, Poppy mercifully winds down a little by the end from her nigh-on insufferably screeching motormouth Cockney persona (a bit of a Leigh staple, this), with the benefit of a few sobering experiences. But it all remains basically life-affirming, and one must infer from this that Leigh wants us to rate excessive positivity over bleak pragmatism, even if the cost is terminal irritation.

6/10

Monday, 31 August 2009

Doubt (John Patrick Shanley, 2008)

In 1964, a priest at a Catholic school is accused by the Principal, a nun, of sexually abusing one of the pupils.
Based on Shanley's own stage play, this is a surprisingly morally complex exploration of a topic that could so easily turn tortuous and sermonising. At one point the realisation hits home that we're more in an exploration of hierarchy and character than one of the nature of abuse. To enable this to unfold without the overbearing burden of condemnation, the true nature of events is left clouded. Our doubt at what occurred is therefore unforcedly mirrored by the doubt the principal protagonists feel towards each other, and eventually towards their faith.
This must be Meryl Streep's finest performance in years, as the self-righteous nun and accuser: what could so easily have turned out as an embittered harridan, a fanatical martinet, comes out instead as a woman on a mission that she must believe in in order to be able to go through with it, and it is quite startling to find a degree of sympathy for her zealotry. Meanwhile, Philip Seymour Hoffman, as the avuncular priest, is at his usual standard of excellence. It becomes as easy to believe him guilty as innocent, and this takes some command of nuance.
Perhaps the stageplay origins are betrayed by the verbiosity present, and some gripes might be had in that there is no real interest shown in a conclusive judgement of an odious issue. No matter: this is an outstanding study of character, not a lecture, and all the more life-like for it.

8/10

Watchmen (Zack Snyder, 2009)

Adaptations of the graphic novels of crusty visionary Alan Moore have not had an entirely happy history, from V for Vendetta to From Hell, and he seems to have disowned this one as a precautionary move. This was a mistake.
Watchmen, published over 20 years ago, is probably Moore's most emblematic work. Set in a parallel 1985, with Nixon still in the White House and the world on the brink of armageddon, it follows a group of former superheroes as a mysterious assassin starts trying to bump them off one by one. A complex plot, at least by the standards of the genre, is held together by the narrative of the vigilante Rorschach, a sort of an unhinged Marlowe with a mask, and contains more darkness than a Batman film could ever hope to entertain. We're firmly in adult territory here: this is an utterly broken world, full of cynical politics, and at the finale the main villain of the piece comes out as far more ambiguous than the mere idea of a superhero film could lead us to expect.
It helps a great deal, of course, that Snyder wisely sticks to the original work, virtually frame by frame, and adds only his one forte: gut-wrenchingly visceral action (see 300). Even the casting is slavishly faithful.
Don't go expecting great depth here, but it will also not insult your intelligence and it's a hell of a ride, far more involving than the much-feted but ultimately lumpy The Dark Knight.

7/10

Burn After Reading (the Coen brothers, 2008)

After a pair of ill-judged adaptations of other people's ideas, the Coens seem to have settled more or less back on track with another of their black comedies. Here, we get something like a butterfly effect of a story on human ineptitude as a stellar cast of characters, each imbued with a single clearly-defined flaw, end up doing each other over in paranoid encounters across Washington, all believing they're somehow caught up in an espionage intrigue. Meanwhile, the CIA watches in bafflement.
So, there's George Clooney as a philanderer, Tilda Swinton as an icy bitch, John Malkovich as an irascible former G-man who's lost his way badly, Frances McDormand as a dippy fitness instructor obsessed with her fading looks and Brad Pitt as her lunkhead friend. The casting itself is wonderful, and the interest of the whole relies a lot on this.
However, unlike in the Coens' last, the searingly dark No Country for Old Men, there's no consistency of tone: it falls between the two stools of relationship-based comedy and thriller, and so requires constant readjustment of viewer response from scene to scene. It's not a painful process by any means, and there's plenty here to entertain, but one hopes that the Coens will take a look at what their knitting is and not hedge their bets next time round.

6/10